“Hollywood Demons” season 2 premieres on Monday, April 20, at 9 p.m. ET/PT on ID and will be available to stream on HBO Max

Unaired fights, secrets revealed, and homicide: the biggest bombshells from the *Jerry Springer *ID documentary

"Hollywood Demons" season 2 premieres on Monday, April 20, at 9 p.m. ET/PT on ID and will be available to stream on HBO Max

By Marina Watts

Marina Watts

Marina Watts is a news writer for with seven years experience covering entertainment, pop culture and celebrity news. Her previous work appears in PEOPLE, Bustle and Newsweek.

EW's editorial guidelines

April 18, 2026 8:00 a.m. ET

Leave a Comment

Jerry Springer on 'The Jerry Springer Show'. Credit:

Ralf-Finn Hestoft/CORBIS/Corbis via Getty

- The sensational stories on *The Jerry Springer Show* went far beyond what audiences saw at home.

- *Hollywood Demons *takes a closer look at the talk show that occasionally packed a punch.

- *Hollywood Demons *season 2 premieres on Monday, April 20, at 9 p.m. ET/PT on ID and will be available to stream on HBO Max. New episodes drop each Monday.**

*The Jerry Springer Show** *might've been sensational to viewers at home, but behind the scenes, the talk show was even more shocking.

Throughout the show's tenure, which ran from 1991 to 2018 featured segments about topics including racism, revealing guests secrets, infidelity, incest and other hot topics. Despite at one point during its tenure becoming the No. 1 talk show in the country, questionable decisions were made when the cameras weren't rolling in order to keep the ratings high.

Springer, who died in 2023, alluded to knowing about what was happening with his production. "Yes, I knew what you guys did. I was so separated from what actually happened, including not knowing ahead of time. They never told me who the guests were going to be," he said in the doc.

Here are the biggest bombshells from the *Hollywood Demons** *episode focused on *The Jerry Springer Show*.**

'The Jerry Springer Show'.

Ralf-Finn Hestoft/CORBIS/Corbis via Getty

This Jerry Springer fight never aired

Associate producer Jimmy "The Hat" Haimann revealed one segment that he felt "responsible" for how it turned out, and it was never broadcast. Haimann, who was on the show from 2002 to 2007, said that there was a love triangle featuring three people from New York.

"One guy was a big guy. The other one was a smaller kid, who had the girl, and the big guy was like, 'Jimmy, I gotta talk to you.' So he throws everybody out of the green room. And I'm like, 'what's up?' He goes, 'I'm gonna kill this kid.'" Haimann told the "big guy" to calm down, who then said he was going to hit the other guy but was concerned he would be stopped for it.

"And I'm thinking to myself, 'alright. I can get this guy to hit him.'" Haimann then gave directives for the guest on how to assault the other guest. "Pretend you're gonna walk up to him and and put your hand out to shake his hand, and close your fist and crack him with the other hand," Haimann recalled telling him. "By the time you hit this kid, he'll be laid out. No one's gonna see it coming."

The producer said that security won't expect a fight since it would look like a reconciliation. The result? The unassuming guest busted their lip open. "There was blood, and I got in big trouble," Haimann concluded. "It was short and quick. I was screamed at...I do feel responsible.

Jerry Springer's cause of death revealed to be from pancreatic cancer

What happened to the biggest talk show icons of the '80s and '90s? Here's the latest on Maury Povich, Jenny Jones, and more

How producers encouraged fights

Former associate producer Houston Curtis revealed the sneaky tactics used to encourage physical fights between guests. "Let's say that I have two brothers in a conflict. When you're prepping the guests, you tell one of them, 'if your brother says something you don't like, you can yell at them, you can get up in his face, you can even spit on him."

"But whatever you do, don't hit him.' And you don't tell the other person any of that," Curtis continued.

"Once you produce one person to get up and spit in someone's face, and then you don't give any instruction to the other one, the other one is going to haul off and knock the hell out of the one who did it, and boom. You got a fight."

Jerry Springer on 'The Jerry Springer Show'.

NBC/Courtesy Everett

Producer admits which segment made him quit the talk show

A "Secrets Revealed" segment led former associate producer Houston Curtis to quit *The Jerry Springer Show*. The "Surprise! I'm a Drag Queen" episode booked "the sweetest little old lady" from Alabama, whose adult son (in his late 30s or early 40s) "had a surprise for her."

"I told her, 'you know, your son has a surprise for you, and he wants to share it with you on *The Jerry Springer Show*," Curtis recalled. He flew her out to Chicago, set her up in a nice hotel, ordered her a limo and brought her to the show.

At the taping, the old woman sat on stage, and her son came out "in full drag" and had written a song that he performed. "All the lyrics written bashing his mother who, to my knowledge at that point, was probably the sweetest person I ever booked on the show. She sat there with so much class and integrity, and just took it."

After the segment ended, Curtis went backstage to check on her, and she burst into tears in his arms. "How could you do this to me," he recalled her saying. "I was only a kid in my 20s but I just knew it was wrong. It was very wrong and it felt horrible. That night, I called Burt Dubrow [the show's creator] and I said, 'Burt, I quit.'"

'The Jerry Springer Show'.

Ralf-Finn Hestoft/CORBIS/Corbis via Getty

Revisiting the *Jerry Springer Show *homicide

During a 2000 "Secret Mistresses Confronted" segment, guest Nancy Campbell-Panitz was confronted by ex-husband Ralf Panitz and his wife, Eleanor Panitz, who alleged that Nancy was stalking Ralf. Nancy, who was falsely told that Ralf was going to reconcile with her on the show, was indifferent to being antagonized by Eleanor and Ralf during the taping. She didn't engage and walked off stage.

When the episode aired two months later in July 2000, Ralf murdered Nancy in her Sarasota, Fla. home after watching it live at a bar and drinking heavily. Hours before the episode aired, Ralf had been barred by a judge from living in Nancy's house. Unbeknownst to the producers, Ralf had a history of domestic violence and was on probation for battery at the time of the taping.

Two years later, Ralf was found guilty of second-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

What producers learned from this segment was to make sure proper background checks were done moving forward.

***Get your daily dose of entertainment news, celebrity updates, and what to watch with our ******EW Dispatch newsletter******.***

How the Jerry Springer producers framed ‘secrets revealed’ segment

*Jerry Springer *producers began to reframe how the "Secrets Revealed" segments were executed. Producers were able to keep the guests in the dark about the secret, but their strategies were stricter than before. Producers would give options of what the secret could be.

"It could be that you're going to find out that you're being cheated on, it could be that you're going to find out that your partner is cheating on you with someone of the same sex, it could be that who you're with is a prostitute," Reena Friedman Watts, who worked on the *Jerry Springer Show *as a producer from 2001-2002 said. "One of them was really it; we just didn't fully give them all of the details."

"We would give them those options of what they might hear before they went out on the stage, so that the show would not be liable," she added. "I still kind of knew what I was doing was wrong, and that's why I quit, actually."

Friedman Watts said that a guest felt like he trusted her and she "misled" him. "He was like, how can you live with yourself," she recalled. "I was like, maybe I am wrecking peoples' lives."

Jerry Springer with guests on 'The Jerry Springer Show'.

NBC/Courtesy Everett

Wrongful death lawsuit

In a May 2018 episode, guest Blake Alvey appeared in a segment where his fiancée revealed she was having an affair with his friend and no longer wanted to marry him. The other man the fiancée was involved with showed up at the soundstage, and there was a scuffle. Alvey was taken by surprise by the segment. Alvey died by suicide 10 days after his episode of *The Jerry Springer Show* aired.

Alvey's family filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the talk show in April 2019, alleging that his death was a "result of extreme emotional distress that was caused by this show and the airing of it," legal expert Charlie Rittgers explained.

"The Jerry Springer Show was designed to humiliate and exploit people like Blake, while the Defendants disregard the devastating consequences that their conduct can have on people's lives. We will fight to hold them accountable," the family’s attorney Brenton Stanley said in a statement, per *TheWrap**.*

The judge ordered that the parties involved in the lawsuit go to arbitration. Several months later, however, the case was dismissed.

Jerry Springer rule documents allegedly ask employees to ‘always play dumb’

Legal expert Charlie Rittgers read over the documents from Alvey's wrongful death lawsuit. He was not involved in the case, but made a startling discovery in the court documents.

According to documents of rules and guidelines that the production team is given regarding guests on the show, the employees are told "to always play dumb" as the first item. "The most important rule to follow on show day is always play dumb. Many guests will ask you all kinds of questions regarding why they are here, [about] the other guests on the show, and various details of their story," Rittgers read.

"You must not mention anything regarding their story. If you ever have any doubts about what you can or cannot say to a guest, then do not say anything at all. As far as they know, you just started." Of the bullet points mentioned in the show rules, nothing reportedly mentioned the wellbeing of the guests.**

*Hollywood Demons *season 2 premieres on Monday, April 20, at 9 p.m. ET on ID and will be available to stream on HBO Max. New episodes drop each Monday.**

- Documentary Shows

Original Article on Source

Source: “EW Documentary”